Can You Work It Out? Our Riddle from the E-News Issue No. 3, June 2026

Two grazing horses

A cowboy, four horses, one goal: reach the saloon as fast as possible. Can you find out how many rides it takes – and in what order?

The Cowboy Problem

A cowboy is ready to call it a day and head to the saloon – but first he needs to drive four horses back to the ranch on his own. Sounds straightforward enough, except for one small logistical snag: he can only ride one horse at a time and lead at most one more alongside him. Two horses at once, no more.

To make things worse, the four animals have very different speeds:

· Horse A: 30 minutes for the route

· Horse B: 40 minutes

· Horse C: 80 minutes

· Horse D: 100 minutes

Whenever he rides with two horses, the slower one sets the pace – so travelling with B and C takes 80 minutes, no matter what.

The question is: How should the cowboy plan his rides to reach the saloon as early as possible?

Solution

The trick is to send the two slowest horses together – that way their combined sluggishness only costs you once. The fastest available horse always serves as the shuttle back to the paddock.

RideRouteTime

1 A + B → Ranch 40 min.

2 A ← back to paddock 30 min.

3 C + D → Ranch 100 min.

4 B ← back to paddock 40 min.

5 A + B → Ranch 40 min.

Total250 min.

The intuitive mistake is to always take the fastest horse along for company – which means dragging A or B through every slow ride with C and D. Send C and D together instead, and you only pay that 100-minute penalty once.